Academy of Country Music
Year : 1997
Category : Top Song of the Year for "This Kiss"

Country Music Association Awards
Year : 1997
Category : Vocal Event of the Year (with Tim McGraw)

Academy of Country Music Awards
Year : 1998
Category : Top Female Vocalist

Academy of Country Music Awards
Year : 1998
Category : Top Vocal Event of the Year (with Tim McGraw)

Academy of Country Music Awards
Year : 1998
Category : Top Music Video of the Year for "It's Your Love" (with Tim McGraw)

Country Music Association Awards
Year : 1998
Category : Music Video of the Year for "It's Your Love" (with Tim McGraw)

TNN/Music City News
Year : 1999
Category : Vocal Collaboration of the Year (with Tim McGraw)

TNN/Music City News
Year : 1999
Category : Video of the Year

TNN/Music City News
Year : 1999
Category: Single of the Year

TNN/Music City News
Year : 1999
Category : Female Artist of the Year

Academy of Country Music Awards
Year : 1999
Category : Top Female Vocalist

Academy of Country Music Awards
Year : 1999
Category : Top Music Video of the Year for "Breathe"

Country Music Association Awards
Year : 1999
Category : Music Video of the Year for "Breathe"

Country Weekly's TNN Awards
Year : 2000
Category : Female Artist of the Year

Country Music Association Awards
Year : 2000
Category : Female Vocalist of the Year

Grammy Awards
Year : 2001
Category : Best Female Country Vocal Performance for "Breathe"

Grammy Awards
Year : 2001
Category : Best Country Collaboration with Vocals for "Let's Make Love" (with Tim McGraw)

Grammy Awards
Year : 2001
Category : Best Country Album for Breathe

Grammy Awards
Year : 2003
Category : Best Female Country Vocal Performance for "Cry"

CMT Flameworthy Video Music Awards
Year : 2003
Category : Hottest Female Video of the Year for "Cry"

People's Choice Awards
Year : 2004
Category : Favorite Female Musical Performer

Grammy Awards
Year: 2006
Category : Best Country Collaboration with Vocals for "Like We Never Loved At All" (with Tim McGraw)

American Music Awards
Year : 2006
Category : Favorite Female Country Artist